Pizza restaurants

Papa Tirozzi Bakery & Pizza

4.8 179 reviews 11:00 AM - 7:00 PM 2165 Portland St, St Johnsbury, VT 05819, United States

Discover this place

When you step into Papa Tirozzi Bakery & Pizza, located at 2165 Portland St, St Johnsbury, VT, you’re not just entering a pizza restaurant—you’re stepping into a taste of home. With a commendable menu that spans hearty pizzas, mouthwatering fish shack platters, and delightful soft serve, every dish tells a story and is crafted with care.

Their pizzas stand out, from the classic Cheese ($17.99) to the indulgent Meat Lovers ($23.99). Diners rave about the authentic flavor that resonates with those from New Jersey, making it a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts. Patrons like Amalio Martinez echo sentiments of nostalgia for slices that remind them of home. And those who adore fresh, homemade tastes will revel in the praises of fresh baked breads and sauces, as highlighted by Adrienne Kuerzi.

Beyond the flavors, customers appreciate the warm, family-oriented atmosphere. Lisa Conn captures this feeling perfectly, applauding the genuine care for patrons that transcends the dining experience. With outdoor seating that's dog-friendly, Papa Tirozzi is the ideal spot to unwind after a day at Dog Mountain. It’s evident that each visit is not just about food, but also about a friendly community embrace.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Outdoor seating
Takeout
Dine-in
Delivery

Highlights

Fast service
Great dessert
Live music
Serves local specialty
Sports

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating

Amenities

Gender-neutral restroom
Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Quiet

Crowd

Family-friendly
Groups
LGBTQ+ friendly
Tourists
Transgender safespace

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Papa Tirozzi Bakery & Pizza before visiting.

Reviews for Papa Tirozzi Bakery & Pizza

4.8

179 reviews

100%

Review highlights

Based on 179 reviews

Papa Tirozzi Bakery & Pizza is widely praised for its authentic and flavorful offerings, particularly its pizza, fresh-baked breads, and generous portions. Customers frequently highlight the quality of ingredients and homemade sauces that evoke a nostalgic, old-country dining experience. The welcoming atmosphere and attentive, friendly staff contribute significantly to the overall positive experience. Additionally, the establishment is noted for being dog-friendly with ample seating both indoors and outdoors, making it a comfortable spot for families and visitors alike. Many reviews emphasize the combination of great food and genuine hospitality, positioning Papa Tirozzi as a standout pizza destination in the St Johnsbury area.

David Gehrer

Aug 31, 2025

A delightful find! The owner was so kind and the food was amazing! The scallops were perfect and the subs (meatball and southender) were huge. The bread and desserts were perfect! We sat outside and enjoyed a beautiful meal.

Adrienne Kuerzi

Jul 28, 2025

Went to Dog Mountain and asked after a dog friendly lunch spot. WOW! We were so impressed with the quality of the food and service! Fresh baked breads and home made sauces so good that even our Jersey sensibilities were singing their praises. Looking for a proper pie that would be home in NY/NJ? This is the place!

Amalio Martinez

Jul 26, 2025

This place is great! The pizza was excellent. I'm from New Jersey and the pizza tasted like a slice from home. The staff is great too. They are super friendly and awesome. The perfect place to go after a trip from Dog Mountain.

Lisa Conn

Jul 14, 2025

IF U ARE VISITING ST JOHNSBURY AND WANT THE OLD COUNTRY FAMILY FEELING THIS IS THE PLACE TO GO The environment is amazing! The people food and dining the area! Such a pleasant experience. Thank u for putting your customers first, making sure we r taken care of. I felt it in every bite U just can't find that anymore!

Carolina Pahl

Jun 20, 2025

Great place for pizza. The dough is delicious and the pizzas are large enough to feed four people (we basically had a whole pizza as leftovers). Ordered two 18" pizzas and a side of mozzarella sticks with 4 drinks. The total was about $65. They are dog friendly and have plenty of seating inside and outside.

Kris D

Jun 15, 2025

Excellent! Great pizza, the subs are amazing and the bakery items are sooooo good. We haven’t had a bad meal yet. My husband loves the seafood (I don’t eat seafood, but he raves about it). I’m 100% Italian and picky about Italian restaurants, Tirozzi’s is excellent!

Alexis Simes

May 20, 2025

If you’re an Italian from Jersey living in the north country, this is your place to get pizza. Everything about their pizza is PROPER!! Crunchy crust (as it should be), beautiful homemade sauce and perfect cheese. The seafood is absolutely delicious and served in satisfying portions, the subs are made with love and served on delicious Italian bread, and the maple ice cream is to die for. The food tastes like home. This place is an absolute gem.